Module Testing

Last Updated : 28 Nov, 2022

Module testing is a type of software testing where individual units or components of the software are tested. The purpose of module testing is to isolate a section of code and verify its correctness. Module testing is usually performed by the development team during the early stages of software development. However, it can also be done by independent testers as part of regression testing. There are various methods of module testing, but the most common one is black-box testing. In black-box testing, the test cases are designed based on the functionality of the code, without taking into consideration its internal structure. Other methods include white-box testing (which looks at the internal structure), grey-box testing (which combines both black-box and white-box testing), and glass-box testing (which tests all possible inputs and outputs). No matter which method you choose, module testing is an important part of ensuring the quality of your software. In this blog post, we will take a closer look at module testing and how it can benefit your software development process.

The following topics will be discussed here:

What is Module Testing?
Objectives of Module Testing
Inputs to Module Testing
Why Module Testing is Important?
Steps for Module Testing
Who does Module Testing?
When Module Testing is done?
Module Testing Best Practices
Module Testing Test Strategy
What are Stubs and Drivers?
Module Testing vs Integration Testing
Module Testing vs Unit Testing
Module Testing Example
Module Testing Tools
Tips for Effective Module Testing

Let’s start discussing each of these topics in detail.

What is Module Testing?

Module testing is a type of software testing that focuses on individual modules or units of code. This is in contrast to system testing, which looks at the entire system as a whole. Module testing is typically done by the developers themselves as they are familiar with the code and can easily identify any potential issues. However, it can also be done by independent testers.

The goal of module testing is to ensure that each module is working correctly and meets all the requirements. This includes verifying the functionality of the code, as well as checking for any errors or bugs. To do this, various test cases are designed that exercise different input values and scenarios. The results of these tests are then analyzed to see if the module meets all the criteria. Module testing is an important part of the software development process and should not be overlooked. It can help to find and fix any defects in the code before they cause problems in the final product.

Objectives of Module Testing

There are several objectives of module testing:

Module working as expected: To ensure that each module is working as expected.
Interfaces working properly: To ensure that the interfaces between modules are working as expected.
Overall system working properly: To ensure that the overall system functions as expected.
Detect errors introduced during development: To find errors that may have been introduced during the development process.
Increase confidence in software: To provide confidence that the system is ready for release.

Inputs to Module Testing

Inputs to module testing include the following:

Requirements: The first input to module testing is the requirements. The tester must have a clear understanding of what the module is supposed to do. This understanding is typically captured in the form of requirements, which can be in the form of user stories, use cases, or functional specifications.
Design: The second input to module testing is the design. The design provides the tester with a high-level view of how the module is implemented. The design should include a description of the interfaces between the module and the rest of the system.
Code: The third input to module testing is the code. The code is the actual implementation of the module. The tester will use the code to execute tests and verify the results.
Test Cases: The fourth input to module testing is the test cases. The test cases define the specific tests that will be executed against the module. The test cases should be designed to exercise all the functionality of the module.
Test Data: The fifth input to module testing is the test data. The test data is used to execute the test cases. The test data should be designed to exercise all the different inputs to the module.
Test Environment: The sixth input to module testing is the test environment. The test environment is the environment in which the tests will be executed. The test environment should be set up so that it is representative of the production environment.
Test Tools: The seventh input to module testing is the test tools. The test tools are the software and hardware that will be used to execute the tests. The test tools should be chosen so that they are appropriate for the type of testing that is being done.

Why Module Testing is Important?

Module testing is a type of software testing that verifies the functionality of individual modules or components of a system. A module can be defined as a self-contained unit of code with a well-defined interface. There are some of the factors why module testing is important:

To ensure each module works correctly: Module testing is important because it helps to ensure that each module or component of a system works as expected and that the interactions between modules are working as intended.
Helps to identify errors early: By verifying the functionality of individual modules, module testing can help to identify errors early in the development process before they become expensive and time-consuming to fix.
Improve software quality: Module testing can help to improve the overall quality of a system by helping to ensure that each module or component meets its requirements and functions as intended.
Prevents errors from propagating: By identifying and resolving errors in individual modules, module testing can help to prevent errors from propagating throughout the system and causing other issues.
The complexity of testing can be managed: Module testing helps to manage the complexity of testing the whole software.
Supports parallel testing: In module testing, multiple modules can be tested simultaneously thus it supports parallel testing.

Steps for Module Testing

Module testing is a type of software testing where individual units/components of the software are tested in isolation. This is to ensure that these units/components work as expected.

There are different ways to carry out module testing:

One way is to use stubs and drivers. Stubs are used to replace the functionality of modules that are not yet implemented. Drivers are used to providing an interface to test the modules.
Another way to carry out module testing is to use mock objects. Mock objects are simulated versions of modules that mimic the behavior of the real modules. This allows you to test the modules without having to depend on other parts of the system working correctly.

When carrying out module testing, it is important to keep in mind that the goal is not just to find bugs but also to verify that the module meets its functional requirements. Therefore, it is important to have a good test plan and test cases that cover all the requirements of the module.

Below are the steps to carry out module testing:

Design test cases: designing test cases in module testing is an important step, here tester must consider the specification of the module and the module’s source code. The module’s logic must be analyzed carefully using the white box testing methods and apply black box testing methods to the module specification to supplement the test cases.
Combine modules for testing: Next step after designing the test cases is to combine the modules for testing. Here, 2 approaches can be used. The tester can either use a non-incremental approach or an incremental approach.
- Incremental approach: In this approach, each module is tested first and then incremented to the tested collection. In this stepwise retesting is done.
- Non-incremental approach: In this approach, all modules are tested independently. First, all modules are combined and then the whole program is tested.
Capture results: The driver is required to supply the test data, monitor the execution, and capture the results.
Report results: Recorded results are reported and carefully analyzed to determine the next step to be taken to resolve the identified errors.

Who does Module Testing?

There are various ways that module testing can be conducted, and it really depends on the type of module being tested as to who is responsible for conducting the tests.

In general, however, it is the responsibility of the module developer to create unit tests for their code and to ensure that all aspects of the module are covered.
These unit tests can then be run by the development team or by a separate QA team to verify the functionality of the code.
If the module is a complex one, or if it is part of a larger system, then it may be necessary to conduct integration testing as well.
This type of testing is typically done by the QA team, and it involves testing how the module interacts with the rest of the system.
This can be a very important step in ensuring that the module works correctly in the overall context of the system.

When Module Testing is Done?

Module testing is done when the module is complete and all its functionality has been tested. A module is a self-contained unit of code that performs a specific task. A module can be a function, a class, or a library.
Module testing is a type of white box testing where the internal structure of the module is known and tests are designed based on this knowledge.

Module testing is typically done using a combination of manual and automated tests. Automated tests can be used to test the functionality of the module, while manual tests can be used to test the user interface and usability of the module. Module testing is an important part of the software development process and can help to ensure that the module is working as intended.

Module Testing Best Practices

There are a few things to keep in mind when writing tests:

Small focused tests: Keep your tests small and focused. Each test should test one specific thing.
Self-contained tests: Make your tests self-contained. This means that each test should not depend on any other test.
Write tests before code: Write your tests before you write the code that they are testing. This will help you think about what you need to test and will make it easier to write tests that are focused and self-contained.
Run tests often: Run your tests often. This will help you catch errors early and will make it easier to find the source of any problems.
Use test runner: Using a test runner will automate the process of running your tests and can provide additional features such as code coverage.
Tests are comprehensive: Make sure your tests are comprehensive. This means testing all the different parts of your code, including the happy path and edge cases.
Keep tests up to date: Keep your tests up to date. As your code changes, so should your tests.
Use meaningful test names: Write meaningful test names. This will make it easier to understand what each test is doing and will make your test suite more readable.
Use assertions: Assertions are like a check that your code is doing what you expect it to. They will make it easier to find problems in your code.
Using tools: Use a tool like JUnit or TestNG. These tools will help you write and run your tests.

Module Testing Test Strategy

A test strategy is a document that outlines the approach that will be taken to test a software application. The test strategy should be aligned with the overall software development strategy and should take into account the risks and objectives associated with the project.

The test strategy should address the following areas:

Test levels: Which types of testing will be performed (e.g. unit, integration, system, acceptance)?
Test types: Which specific tests will be performed (e.g. functional, non-functional, regression, stress)?
Test tools: Which tools will be used to support the testing effort?
Test environment: What environment will be used for testing (e.g. development, staging, production)?
Test data: What data will be used for testing?
Test coverage: What areas of the application will be covered by tests?
Exit criteria: What conditions must be met before testing can be considered complete?

The test strategy should be reviewed and updated regularly as the project progresses and as new risks and objectives are identified.

Module testing is conducted by dividing the process into 2 parts:

Component testing in small (CTIS): It is performed in complete isolation without integrating one component with another.
Component testing in large (CTIL): It is performed without isolating components from each other as when one component is dependent on another component, isolating them may lead to functionality issues.

What are Stubs and Drivers?

Stub: A stub is a small piece of code that typically stands in for a larger component or system.

One common use of a stub is in testing. When testing code that interacts with a large or complex system, it is often impractical or impossible to test against the actual system. In these cases, a stub can be used to stand in for the system. The stub code may simply return hard-coded values, or it may execute some basic functionality to mimic the system.
Another common use of stubs is in application integration. When two applications need to communicate with each other, they often do so through an intermediary component called a messaging bus. The applications send messages to the bus, which then routes the messages to the appropriate destination. The applications are not aware of the existence of the other applications; they simply interact with the bus.

Driver: A driver is a software component that provides a specific interface to a hardware device. In many cases, a driver acts as a translator between the hardware device and the software application that uses the device.

A driver is typically a piece of low-level code that provides an interface to a hardware device. The driver code is usually specific to the device and the operating system. Drivers typically handle tasks such as memory management, I/O operations, and interrupts. Most devices require a driver in order to work properly. For example, a video card needs a driver in order to display images on the screen. A printer needs a driver in order to print documents.
In some cases, a device may have multiple drivers. For example, a video card may have a separate driver for each operating system that it supports. In other cases, a single driver may work with multiple devices.
For example, a printer driver may work with multiple printers from different manufacturers.

The line between a stub and a driver is often blurry. In many cases, a piece of code may start out as a stub and evolve into a driver over time. For example, a video card driver may start out as a simple stub that only supports a small number of display modes. As the driver is further developed, it may gain support for more display modes, more features, and more hardware devices.

Module Testing vs Integration Testing

Below are the differences between module testing and integration testing:

Parameters	Module Testing	Integration Testing
Objective	Tests the functionality of a single module.	Tests the interaction between components.
Error location	Identifies errors in the functionality of the module.	Identifies errors in the interfaces and dependencies between components.
Testing order	Is typically performed before integration testing.	Is typically performed after unit testing.
Access to source code	Does not require access to the source code.	May require access to the source code.
Requirement of test harness or driver	Does not require special test harnesses or drivers.	May require special test harnesses or drivers.
Testing level	Is typically performed at the component level.	Can be performed at the component, subsystem, or system level.
Automatic/ Manual	Is often performed automatically.	Is often performed manually.
Time taken	Usually takes less time to execute than integration tests.	Usually takes longer to execute than unit tests.
Cost	Is less expensive to execute than integration tests.	Is more expensive to execute than unit tests.

Module Testing vs Unit Testing

Below are the differences between module testing and unit testing:

Parameters	Module Testing	Unit Testing
Testing level	Module testing is done at the tester’s level.	Unit testing is done at the developer’s level
Testing approach	Module testing is a top-down approach.	Unit testing is a bottom-up approach
Before/ After integration testing	Module testing is done after the integration of the modules.	Unit testing is done before the integration of the modules
Objective	Module testing is done to test the functionality of the module.	Unit testing is done to test the functionality of the code
Who performs?	Module testing, the test cases are written by the testers.	In unit testing, the test cases are written by the developers
Testing input	Module testing is done on the module.	Unit testing is done on the code
Blackbox/ Whitebox testing	Module testing can be either white box or black box testing.	Unit testing is white-box testing
Testing site	Module testing is done at the customer’s site.	Unit testing is done at the developer’s site
Scope	The scope of module testing is larger than the scope of unit testing.	The scope of unit testing is smaller than the scope of module testing.
Testing machine	Module testing is done on the remote machine.	Unit testing is done on the local machine

Module Testing Example

Module testing is testing the functionality of an individual module or component.

For example, testing the login functionality of a website. This would involve testing the input fields, the functionality of the login button, and the correct redirection to the home page after a successful login.
Other examples of module testing include testing the search functionality of a website or testing the Add to Cart button on an eCommerce website.

Module Testing Tools

Module testing tools help test individual software components or modules. Common module testing tools include:

Static code analysis tools: These analyze source code for potential bugs without actually executing the code. Examples include FindBugs, Fortify, and Klocwork.
Unit testing frameworks: These allow you to create and run tests on individual modules to ensure they work as expected. Examples include JUnit and NUnit.
Mutation testing tools: These modify your source code in small ways and then re-run your tests to see if any bugs are found. This can help find hidden defects that might not be caught by traditional unit tests. Examples include Major Mutation and mutation++.

Tips for Effective Module Testing

There is no one-size-fits-all answer to the question of how to effectively test modules, as the approach that works best will vary depending on the specific module being tested and the software system as a whole. However, there are some general tips that can help make module testing more effective:

Define clear objectives for the test: What are you trying to achieve? What do you need to know in order to determine whether the module is working correctly?
Test plan that covers all aspects: Design a test plan that covers all aspects of the module. This should include both functional and non-functional tests.
Test cases that represent real-world scenarios: Create test cases that are representative of real-world scenarios. This will help ensure that the module is tested thoroughly and that any potential problems are uncovered.
Track results carefully: Execute the tests and track results carefully. This will enable you to identify any issues that need to be addressed and also allows you to see how the module performs under various conditions.
Perform regression testing after incorporating changes: Make sure to perform regression testing after making changes to the module or other parts of the system. This ensures that previously identified issues have not been reintroduced and that new functionality does not break existing functionality.

Suggest improvement

Formal Testing

Share your thoughts in the comments