Democratic Reforms in the Middle East: Democracy in the Middle East is influenced by geographical, historical, and cultural factors. But this process of democratization can’t be purely practical or just. In the end, the ultimate goal is to recreate the society thus laying the foundation for nonviolent interactions. This process faced some challenges that came with colonization, economic differences, religion, and culture.
The Arab Spring, the first Arab revolution brought both long-term and sudden consequences including the removal of authoritarian rule, the granting of social and political rights, the development of political spheres, and different international reactions.
In this article, we will explore the democratic reforms in the Middle East, with its history, types of government, effects of the arab revolution in the Middle East, and the current state of democracy in it.
About the Middle East
The Middle East has a rich historical heritage, with ancient civilizations such as Mesopotamia, Persia, and Egypt contributing to human civilization. The region has seen the rise and fall of various empires, including the Ottoman Empire, the Safavids, and the Abbasids.
It has been a region marked by political and territorial conflicts. The Arab-Israeli conflict, the Iran-Iraq War, and ongoing conflicts in Syria and Yemen are examples of long-standing issues. Geopolitical tensions and external interventions have also played a role in shaping the region’s modern history.
Map of Middle East
Democracy in the Middle East
Democracy in the Middle East is multifaceted and shaped by historical, cultural, and geopolitical factors contributing to diverse manifestations across the region. Nations like Tunisia have made notable progress in establishing a democratic post-Arab Spring, while others like Syria and Yemen continue to live with political instability and conflicts. The discourse on democracy in the Middle East has been shaped by both external and internal factors.
History of Democratic Reforms in the Middle East
The history of democracy in the Middle East is varied and complex reflecting different political landscapes of the region. Ancient civilizations like Persia and Mesopotamia laid the foundation for governance with elements of modern democracy that emerged in the 20th century. After the collapse of the Ottoman Empire after the First World War the nations in the middle east started experimenting with democratic reforms of governance. This journey of reforms was marked by challenges like periods of authoritarian rule, social unrest, and geopolitical conflicts. In recent years the Middle East has seen both setbacks and progress. Some nations experienced a push for political reforms while others continued with difficulty in unbalancing traditional and modern governance structures. The history of democracy in the Middle East reflects the continuous evolution shaped by geographical, historical, and cultural dynamics.
Types of Governments in the Middle East
The Middle East is highly authoritarian. Some countries have an individual ruler ruling the country with a near absolute power. However, this does not reflect that there is no existence of democratic governments. The countries in the Middle East mainly have four types of governments:
- Absolute Monarchies: An absolute monarchy is a form of government where a dictator or king has complete power to run the government. The Middle East is home to the last of the remaining absolute monarchies in the world which includes countries like Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Oman, etc.
- Constitutional Monarchies: A constitutional monarchy is a type of government where the power is divided between a king and a parliamentary government. Morocco and Jordan are good examples of constitutional monarchies in the Middle East.
- Theocrat Government: This is a type of government where the state is governed by a religious head. Iran is the best example of this type of government in the Middle East.
- Parliamentary Republics: In parliamentary republics, the government is formed by a political party that wins a majority of seats in parliamentary elections. Egypt, Lebanon, Israel, Algeria, Yemen, Turkey, and Tunisia are the best examples of parliamentary republics in the Middle East.
Democratic Deficit in the Middle East
The publication of the United Nations Development Program Arab Human Development Report of 2002 drew attention to the democratic deficit in the Arab countries which started the discussion in public forums. The shift in US policy after the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, intensified the need for political reforms in the region. The Bush administration’s freedom agenda addressed the root cause of terrorism by promoting economic and democratic reform in the Middle East. This triggered a response from governments and led them toward political reform.
Arab Spring: The First Arab Revolution in the Middle East
Arab Spring also known as the first Arab revolution was a wave of pro-democratic protests in the Middle East and North Africa between 2010 and 2011. This challenged Authoritarian regimes in many regions. The uprisings began in Egypt and Tunisia which inspired the Arab countries. Although not all the countries where the revolution took place was successful. The protestors were met with violence by their country’s security forces for expressing economic and political discourse.
Causes of Arab Spring in the Middle East
The uprisings were against the long-term despotic rule of authoritarian rulers. The common slogan of protest throughout the Arab Spring was “ the people want to bring down the regime.” The causes of Arab Spring can be described in the following way:
Economic Causes
The economic cause can also be further categorized into sub-divisions that fueled the uprising across the Middle East and North Africa. Firstly global crises played a very important role and impacted the states exporting oils as their GDP levels were affected during the downturn in oil prices in 2008-2009 as the reduced demand in Europe and America led to economic challenges. Secondly, the food crisis and its prices also acted as a catalyst in the political unrest. The spiked prices of food fueled the public protest and contributed to overall discontent. Lastly, unemployment affected nations like Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia. Arab Springs was marked by significant youth with a high unemployment level. All these collectively contributed to economic crises that fueled protests during the Arab Spring.
Social Causes
Arab Spring was also significantly influenced by social factors. According to the demographics of the region, 30 percent of the population in the area was between 15 to 29 years of age which caused a high unemployment rate. The boost in education levels over the last three decades heightened the expectation for better socio-economic conditions creating a politically aware youth that played a crucial role in fueling the Arab Spring. This also played a crucial role in aligning modern theories of democratization which put forward that education and economic development are important parts of the economic process.
Sudden Causes
Several sudden causes ignited the uprisings in the Middle East. The tragic death of Mohamed Bouazizi a street vendor in Tunis in December 2010 was an important event in the Tunisian revolution that set motion to a series of protests across the Arab world. Also, the unexpected toppling of the Tunisian president Zine El Abidine Ben Ali in January 2011 became a uniting point in other Arab states to stand against the despotic rulers.
Consequence of the First Arabian Revolution in the Middle East
The protest movement was a unique struggle for democracy across the Middle East. The protest continued for years in addition to another wave of protest in the Arab world in the late 2010s and early 2020s. It is difficult to predict the consequences of the Arab Spring. Although some consequences can be predicted keeping the long-term process in mind. Let’s discuss some consequences-
Removal of Authoritarian Rule
One immediate consequence was the removal of authoritarian rule in Egypt, Tunisia, and Libya. Leaders in these regions held power for decades which led to widespread public discontent and demand for political reform.
Grant of Social and Political Rights
In response to this leaders of neighboring countries like Morocco, Oman, Saudi Arabia, and Bahrain granted social and economic rights to their citizens. This was done to prevent the population from following the path of what happened in Egypt, Tunisia, and Libya.
Development of the political sphere for public
Despite these challenges, there was the emergence of political spheres for public to openly discuss politics, participate in shaping the political landscape of the country, and voice their political opinions. This allowed the Arab people to actively contribute to democratic transition and political change.
International reaction
The international community viewed this as a significant step towards democracy for Arabs. The reactions varied reflecting geopolitical considerations and the pursuit of influence in the region.
Gaps in the Democracy in the Middle East
The gaps in the democracy of the Middle East are multifaceted and rooted in geographical, historical, religious, cultural, and economic factors. Historically the imposition of colonial rule by the French and British played an important role in designing the political landscape of the region. The rise of radical nationalism under colonial rule further worsened the challenges with the republics inheriting authoritarian legacies that are still standing today as they implemented measures to limit public participation.
Geographically the way these countries were created in the Middle East and their closeness to Europe made it easier for these authoritarian leaders to stay in power. Economic differences ranging from extreme poverty to extraordinary wealth also played a crucial role in resource scarcities affecting democratization in the Middle East. In addition to this, the religious and cultural role of Islam suggests that there is a complex relationship between Islam, governance, and political preferences.
When we see the current landscape of democratic reforms in the Middle East it is marked by both challenges and progress. Countries like Tunisia have made successful steps towards establishing democratic institutions since the Arab Spring, while others like Yemen and Syria are continuing with long conflicts that affect the prospect of political transformations. Gulf nations have undergone different political and social reforms in response to increased public participation but the pace differs regionally. The complex historical legacies and leadership strategies have shaped the diverse democratic reforms contributing to the evolving political change in the Middle East.
In conclusion, to achieve a stable democracy in the Middle East it is required to address all these challenges as mentioned above while considering the diversity of the region. Progress has been made but the journey of democratization is still ongoing marked by a revolution like the Arab Spring that emphasizes the advancement that they have made in this process.
People Also Read:
Are there any democracies in the Middle East?
Yes, Israel is the only democratic country in the region that qualifies as a flawed democracy according to the Economist Group’s Democracy Index 2022.
Which is the first Arab Revolution?
Arab Spring also known as the first Arab revolution was a wave of pro-democratic protests in the Middle East and North Africa between 2010 and 2011
What types of governments are most common in the Middle East?
The Middle East is a highly authoritarian region. Absolute monarchies are common in the Middle East with Saudi Arabia and other kingdoms.
Is democracy possible in the Middle East?
Achieving democracy in the Middle East may face challenges due to many factors but it is possible with thoughtful reforms and commitment to governance.
What is Arab Spring?
Arab Spring was a wave of pro-democratic protests in the Middle East and North Africa between 2010 and 2011. This challenged Authoritarian regimes in many regions. The uprisings began in Egypt and Tunisia which inspired the Arab countries.
Share your thoughts in the comments
Please Login to comment...