Territorial Disputes in China

China’s territorial disputes have become a focal point of regional tension and international concern due to their complex nature and far-reaching implications. China has emerged as a major force in the geopolitical scene of the twenty-first century. But as it grows, China becomes caught up in a web of territorial disputes with its neighbors, which exacerbates tensions and casts doubt on the stability of the area.

These conflicts, which involve the South China Sea, Taiwan, the East China Sea, and the boundary between India and China, influence not only how China interacts with its neighbors but also global affairs more broadly.

Let us discuss this in detail!

China Territorial Disputes: An Overview

Territory/Region	Countries/Entities Involved	Key Issues
South China Sea	China, Vietnam, Philippines, Malaysia, Brunei, Taiwan	Sovereignty over islands, maritime rights, resources, and navigation routes. China asserts claims based on the “nine-dash line.”
East China Sea	China, Japan, Taiwan	Territorial sovereignty over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands. Tensions over maritime boundaries, resources, and military activities in the region.
India-China Border	China, India	Territorial claims along the Line of Actual Control (LAC) in the Himalayan region, including disputes over Aksai Chin and Arunachal Pradesh.
Taiwan	China, Taiwan	China considers Taiwan as a part of its territory under the “One China” policy. Taiwan operates as a separate democratic entity with its own government and military.

Historical Background of China’s territorial disputes

• China’s territorial disputes have deep historical roots, with many stemming from imperial expansions, colonial legacies, and unresolved border issues. The Qing Dynasty, for example, expanded China’s territory through conquest and treaties, establishing borders that later became subject to dispute during the modern era.
• During the 19th and 20th centuries, China faced significant territorial losses due to colonial incursions, foreign invasions, and unequal treaties. These losses included territories ceded to European powers, Japan, and Russia, as well as regions such as Tibet and Xinjiang, which experienced varying degrees of autonomy or control.
• The aftermath of World War II and the Chinese Civil War further complicated territorial issues, leading to the establishment of new borders and unresolved disputes with neighboring countries.

Major Territorial Disputes

Some of the major territorial disputes involving China include:

South China Sea Dispute

The South China Sea dispute is a big argument between countries over who controls certain islands and seas in that area. China says it has historic rights over most of the sea, but other countries like Vietnam and the Philippines also claim parts of it. China has been building islands and military bases there, which has made other countries worried and led to conflicts. It’s a big problem because the area is important for trade, and if things get worse, it could lead to fighting. People are trying to talk and find a peaceful solution, but it’s not easy.

There are worries about the possibility of escalation and conflict because the issue has resulted in maritime incidents, confrontations, and sporadic clashes between claimant governments. Major powers have also expressed interest in the South China Sea due to its strategic significance for international trade and energy supplies, which makes efforts to settle the conflict amicably more difficult.

East China Sea Dispute

The East China Sea dispute is another big argument between China and Japan over some small islands. Both countries say the islands belong to them. The tension has led to disagreements and sometimes even clashes. It’s a problem because the area is important for fishing and has a lot of oil and gas underneath. People are trying to talk and solve the problem without fighting, but it’s not easy.

The East China Sea dispute is about a group of small islands called the Senkaku Islands, which Japan controls, and China calls them the Diaoyu Islands. Both countries claim ownership of these islands because they believe they’re important for historical and strategic reasons. The islands are in a part of the sea that’s rich in fish and might have oil and natural gas under the seabed, which makes them valuable.

India-China Border Dispute

The India-China border dispute is about disagreements between India and China over where their border should be. Both countries have different ideas about where the border lies, especially in a mountainous area called the Himalayas. This has led to conflicts and even a war between them in the past.

• The main areas of disagreement are in places like Aksai Chin in the west and Arunachal Pradesh in the east. Both countries claim these areas as their own, which has led to tensions and occasional clashes between their soldiers.
• Finding a solution to this dispute is tricky because it’s not just about drawing lines on a map. It’s also about historical claims, national pride, and strategic interests. Both India and China want to avoid fighting again, so they’re trying to talk and negotiate to find a peaceful solution. However, it’s a complicated issue that’s been going on for a long time, and finding a resolution won’t be easy.

Taiwan China Dispute

The Taiwan-China dispute is about who should govern the island of Taiwan. China claims that Taiwan is part of its territory and wants to reunify it with the mainland, while Taiwan sees itself as a separate country with its own government, military, and laws.

• This disagreement stems from a civil war in China in the 1940s, after which the defeated Nationalist government fled to Taiwan and established its own rule there. Meanwhile, the Communist Party took control of mainland China. Since then, Taiwan has developed its own democratic system and has become economically prosperous.
• China considers Taiwan a renegade province and has threatened to use force to bring it under its control if necessary. However, Taiwan wants to maintain its independence and international recognition as a separate entity.
• The Taiwan-China dispute is a sensitive issue in international relations, with countries around the world having to navigate their diplomatic ties with both Taiwan and China carefully. The situation remains complex, with ongoing tensions and occasional military posturing, making it a significant factor in regional stability and global politics.

Parties Involved and Claims

Here are the parties involved in China’s major territorial disputes and their respective claims:

1. South China Sea Dispute:
   • China: Asserts sovereignty over most of the South China Sea based on its “nine-dash line” claim, which encompasses the majority of the sea area, including the Spratly Islands, Paracel Islands, Scarborough Shoal, and other features.
   • Vietnam: Claims sovereignty over the Paracel Islands and parts of the Spratly Islands, asserting historical evidence and proximity as the basis for its claims.
   • Philippines: Claims sovereignty over parts of the Spratly Islands, including the Reed Bank and Scarborough Shoal, based on proximity, historical evidence, and the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).
   • Malaysia: Asserts sovereignty over some features in the Spratly Islands and disputes China’s expansive claims, citing UNCLOS and historical presence as the basis for its claims.
   • Brunei: Claims maritime territory in the South China Sea but does not have significant overlapping claims with China.
   • Taiwan: Like China, Taiwan claims sovereignty over the entire South China Sea based on historical records and the “nine-dash line.”
2. Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands Dispute:
   • China: Asserts sovereignty over the Senkaku Islands (Diaoyu Islands) based on historical records dating back to the Ming Dynasty, viewing them as inherent Chinese territory.
   • Japan: Claims sovereignty over the Senkaku Islands based on its control of the islands since the late 19th century, arguing that there was no dispute until the 1970s when potential oil and gas reserves were discovered nearby.

Geopolitical Implications of China’s territorial disputes

China’s territorial disputes have significant geopolitical implications, influencing regional dynamics, global power structures, and international relations. Some of the key geopolitical implications include:

1. Regional Security Tensions: China’s assertiveness in its territorial claims, particularly in the South China Sea, East China Sea, and along its land borders, has heightened tensions with neighboring countries. These tensions have led to increased military activities, including naval patrols, airspace violations, and territorial incursions, raising concerns about the risk of armed conflict and destabilization in the region.
2. Strategic Competition: China’s territorial disputes contribute to strategic competition with other major powers, particularly the United States and Japan. The U.S., as a strategic ally to several countries involved in China’s disputes, including Japan and the Philippines, has intensified its presence in the Asia-Pacific region to counterbalance China’s growing influence, leading to a broader geopolitical rivalry between the two superpowers.
3. Maritime Security and Freedom of Navigation: Disputes in the South China Sea have raised concerns about maritime security, freedom of navigation, and access to critical sea lanes. China’s construction of artificial islands, military installations, and imposition of maritime claims based on its “nine-dash line” have challenged international maritime norms and sparked tensions with countries reliant on the South China Sea for trade and navigation.
4. Economic Interests and Resource Access: Control over disputed territories, particularly in the South China Sea, offers access to valuable natural resources such as oil, gas, and fisheries, as well as strategic shipping routes. Competition for these resources has economic implications for regional states and global markets, fueling disputes over sovereignty and maritime boundaries

International Law Related to China’s territorial disputes

The international law related to China’s territorial disputes encompasses various legal principles, treaties, and conventions that govern the resolution of territorial disputes and the delimitation of maritime boundaries. Some key aspects of international law relevant to China’s territorial disputes include:

1. United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS):
   • UNCLOS is a comprehensive international treaty that establishes the legal framework for maritime rights and responsibilities. It defines maritime zones, including territorial seas, exclusive economic zones (EEZs), and the continental shelf, and sets out rules for their delimitation.
   • UNCLOS provides guidelines for resolving disputes related to maritime boundaries, including through negotiation, mediation, and, if necessary, international arbitration.
2. Territorial Sovereignty:
   • Under customary international law, states have the right to territorial sovereignty, which includes the exclusive authority to govern their territory and exercise jurisdiction over it.
   • Territorial sovereignty is based on historical title, effective occupation, and the consent of other states, among other factors.
3. Historical Claims:
   • Historical claims are often invoked by states to assert sovereignty over disputed territories. However, international law requires that historical claims be supported by continuous and peaceful exercise of sovereignty, as well as recognition by other states.

Diplomatic Efforts and Resolution Attempts

Diplomatic efforts and resolution attempts regarding China’s territorial disputes have involved a variety of approaches, including bilateral negotiations, multilateral forums, confidence-building measures, and third-party mediation. Some notable diplomatic efforts and resolution attempts include:

1. Bilateral Negotiations:
   • Direct talks between China and the disputing parties have been attempted to address specific territorial disputes. For example, China has engaged in bilateral negotiations with countries like Vietnam and the Philippines to manage tensions in the South China Sea.
2. ASEAN-China Dialogue:
   • The Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) has sought to facilitate dialogue and cooperation between its member states and China through mechanisms such as the ASEAN-China Dialogue Relations. This platform aims to address regional security issues, including territorial disputes, through peaceful means and mutual respect for sovereignty.
3. ASEAN Regional Forum (ARF):
   • The ARF, a multilateral security dialogue involving ASEAN member states and external partners, provides a forum for discussing regional security issues, including territorial disputes. While not specifically focused on resolving disputes, the ARF promotes confidence-building measures and diplomatic dialogue among stakeholders.
4. Code of Conduct (COC) in the South China Sea:
   • ASEAN and China have been working towards the development of a legally binding Code of Conduct (COC) in the South China Sea aimed at managing disputes, preventing conflict, and promoting maritime cooperation. Negotiations for the COC have been ongoing for years, with both sides expressing commitment to its eventual conclusion.

Current Status and Future Outlook

The current status of China’s territorial disputes varies depending on the specific issue, but overall, tensions persist in many of these contested areas. Here’s an overview of the current status and future outlook:

1. South China Sea Dispute:
   • Tensions in the South China Sea remain high, with China continuing to assert its expansive maritime claims and increase military activities in the region. Despite ongoing negotiations for a Code of Conduct (COC) between China and ASEAN, progress has been slow, and there are concerns about China’s willingness to comply with international law.
2. Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands Dispute:
   • Tensions between China and Japan over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands persist, with both countries engaging in regular maritime patrols and military exercises in the area. The dispute has strained bilateral relations and raised concerns about the risk of unintended escalation.
3. Taiwan Dispute:
   • The territorial dispute between China and Taiwan remains unresolved, with China continuing to assert its sovereignty over the island. Tensions have escalated in recent years, with China increasing military activities near Taiwan and Taiwan bolstering its defense capabilities.

Conclusion: China’s territorial disputes

In conclusion, China’s territorial disputes represent a significant challenge to regional stability and international relations. From the South China Sea to the Taiwan Strait, the East China Sea, and the India-China border, these disputes involve complex historical, geopolitical, and strategic considerations. China’s assertive actions in advancing its territorial claims have heightened tensions with neighboring countries and raised concerns among the broader international community. The disputes have led to maritime confrontations, occasional military standoffs, and diplomatic friction, posing risks of escalation and conflict in the region.

FAQs: China’s territorial disputes

What are the disputes in the China Sea?

Conflicting island and marine claims in the South China Sea by many sovereign entities, including the People’s Republic of China (PRC), Taiwan (Republic of China/ROC), Brunei, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Vietnam, are known as territorial disputes in the region.

What is the island dispute in China?

There is a continuous territorial conflict involving the Spratly Islands that involves Brunei, China, Malaysia, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Vietnam.

How many countries does China have border disputes with?

Territory dispute involving the PRC as of 2024. Resolved disputes, such as the ones with Russia, Mongolia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Myanmar, North Korea, Nepal, Tajikistan continue to be disputed by the ROC.

Which country has the most territorial disputes?

China and India have troublesome neighbors, which is one of the main causes of their territorial conflicts.

Has India lost territory to China?

NASA WorldWind image depicts a portion of the Pangong Tso-Chushul combat area along the LAC. China has gained 2,000 square kilometers of Indian territory since June 2020.