# UGC-NET | UGC NET CS 2015 Dec – II | Question 6

• Last Updated : 01 May, 2018

Which of the following arguments are not valid ?
(a)“If Gora gets the job and works hard, then he will be promoted. If Gora gets promotion, then he will be happy. He will not be happy, therefore, either he will not get the job or he will not work hard”.
(b)“Either Puneet is not guilty or Pankaj is telling the truth. Pankaj is not telling the truth, therefore, Puneet is not guilty”.
(c)If n is a real number such that n>1, then n2>1. Suppose that n2>1, then n>1.
Codes :

(A) (a) and (c)
(B) (b) and (c)
(C) (a), (b) and (c)

(D) (a) and (b)

Explanation:

• “If Gora gets the job and works hard, then he will be promoted. If Gora gets promotion, then he will be happy. He will not be happy, therefore, either he will not get the job or he will not work hard”. This is not valid argument.
• “Either Puneet is not guilty or Pankaj is telling the truth. Pankaj is not telling the truth, therefore, Puneet is not guilty”.This is valid argument.
• If n is a real number such that n>1, then n2>1. Suppose that n2>1, then n>1. This is valid argument.

So, option (B) is correct.

Quiz of this Question

My Personal Notes arrow_drop_up