Open In App

Difference Between Manganese and Magnesium

Improve
Improve
Like Article
Like
Save
Share
Report

If you have ever gone through a periodic table, then you might know that are many elements that sound pretty similar, but in fact, they are quite distinctive. Magnesium (Mg) & Manganese (Mn) are two such elements from the family of metals. Both of these elements hold commercial as well as biological importance, as these elements are present in the body, as well as some of their compounds are of high commercial value. Thus in this article, some of the notable differences between the two and their characteristics are discussed. 

Difference Between Manganese and Magnesium

Properties

Manganese

Magnesium

Chemical properties With high melting and boiling temperatures, moderate electronegativity, and a range of oxidation states, manganese is a transition metal. Magnesium is an alkaline earth metal having just two typical oxidation states, low electronegativity, and relatively low melting and boiling points.
Occurrence  Manganese can be extracted by smelting or leaching from ores, soil, and water. Magnesium can be obtained by electrolysis or thermal reduction and is primarily found in seawater, minerals, and brines.
Biological role As a cofactor for numerous enzymes involved in metabolism, bone growth, and antioxidant defense, manganese is a crucial trace element. Magnesium is a necessary element that aids in energy metabolism contributes to heart rhythm and muscle function regulation, and serves as a structural component of bones and teeth.
Toxicity Neurological issues can result from excessive manganese exposure, especially in work contexts. Magnesium poisoning is rare, however excessive magnesium supplementation can result in diarrhea, nausea, and other gastrointestinal symptoms.
 
Common uses Steel and other alloys, batteries, fertilizers, ceramics, and pigments are all products made from manganese. Magnesium is frequently utilized in the manufacturing of aluminum alloys, die casting, batteries, flares, and fireworks in addition to being used in antacids and laxatives for medical purposes.
Found in food Whole grains, nuts, green vegetables, tea, and other foods all contain manganese. Among other places, green vegetables, nuts, seeds, and whole grains are suppliers of magnesium. 
Health benefits  Manganese may help reduce inflammation, protect against oxidative stress, and support brain health, among other potential benefits.  Among other potential advantages, magnesium may aid in lowering anxiety, enhancing sleep, and supporting cardiovascular health.

There are numerous distinctions between manganese and magnesium in terms of their chemical and physical properties, reactivity, biological significance, natural sources, and uses. We can learn more by contrasting these characteristics and greater comprehension of the uses and qualities that make them special.

Properties of Manganese and Magnesium

Magnesium:

  • Magnesium is a thin metal with just about two-thirds the density of aluminum.
  • It requires particular management during manufacture and usage because of its relatively low melting point and high degree of reactivity, which makes it vulnerable to corrosion.
  • Due to its excellent strength-to-weight ratio, magnesium is advantageous in situations where weight reduction is crucial.
  • Magnesium is useful in a variety of mechanical and electrical applications because it is an excellent conductor of heat and electricity and has good damping qualities.
  • Magnesium is frequently employed in applications where high energy output is required, including fireworks and flares, due to its reactivity and flammability.
  • Magnesium is also employed in medicine, especially as an antacid and laxative.

Manganese:

  • Manganese is a silvery-gray metal that is tough and brittle.
  • It does not tarnish readily and is rather stable in the air.
  • Manganese is frequently referred to as a “ferroalloy” since it is an essential component of many alloys, particularly steel.
  • Manganese is beneficial in situations where strength and durability are crucial since it has a high melting point and is rather dense.
  • Manganese is useful in a variety of electrical and magnetic applications since it is a good conductor of electricity and has good magnetic characteristics.
  • Besides being utilized as a pigment in paints, ceramics, and other products, manganese was formerly used in the manufacture of glass and steel.

Conclusion

Manganese and magnesium are two distinctive elements with unique traits, qualities, and applications. Magnesium is a light metal that is used in the creation of lightweight alloys and incendiary bombs, whereas manganese is a hard, brittle metal that is utilized in the production of steel, alloys, and batteries. We may better appreciate these two elements’ distinctive qualities and uses if we comprehend how they differ from one another.

FAQs:

Q1. What are some common uses of Manganese and Magnesium?

Ans. Batteries, fertilizers, ceramics, pigments, steel, and other alloys are all made with manganese. Magnesium is utilized in the manufacture of aluminum alloys, die casting, batteries, flares, and fireworks in addition to being used in antacids and laxatives for medical purposes.

Q2. Are Manganese and Magnesium toxic?

Ans. The body requires trace amounts of both manganese and magnesium, which are both important minerals. However, excessive magnesium consumption can result in diarrhea, nausea, and other gastrointestinal complaints, whereas excessive manganese exposure can induce brain issues.

Q3. Can Manganese and Magnesium be found in food?

Ans. Yes, a number of foods include magnesium and manganese. While green vegetables, nuts, seeds, and whole grains contain magnesium, whole grains, leafy vegetables, nuts, and tea contain manganese.

Q4. How are Manganese and Magnesium different in terms of their biological role?

Ans. For the cofactors of enzymes involved in metabolism, bone growth, and antioxidant defense, manganese is necessary. Magnesium, on the other hand, is crucial for energy metabolism, has a structural role in bones, and aids in heart rhythm and muscle function control.

Q5. What are some common health benefits of Manganese and Magnesium?

Ans. Magnesium and manganese are both essential for sustaining excellent health. Magnesium may promote sleep, help with anxiety reduction, and support cardiovascular health, whereas manganese may help with inflammation reduction, oxidative stress protection, and brain health support. To fully comprehend their possible health advantages, more study is necessary. 


Last Updated : 24 Feb, 2023
Like Article
Save Article
Previous
Next
Share your thoughts in the comments
Similar Reads