In C++, pre-increment (or pre-decrement) can be used as l-value, but post-increment (or post-decrement) can not be used as l-value.
For example, following program prints a = 20 (++a is used as l-value)
// CPP program to illustrate// Pre-increment (or pre-decrement)#include <cstdio> int main(){ int a = 10; ++a = 20; // works printf("a = %d", a); getchar(); return 0;} |
a = 20
The above program works whereas the following program fails in compilation with error “non-lvalue in assignment” (a++ is used as l-value)
// CPP program to illustrate// Post-increment (or post-decrement)#include <cstdio> int main(){ int a = 10; a++ = 20; // error printf("a = %d", a); getchar(); return 0;} |
prog.cpp: In function 'int main()':
prog.cpp:6:5: error: lvalue required as left operand of assignment
a++ = 20; // error
^
How ++a is different from a++ as lvalue?
It is because ++a returns an lvalue, which is basically a reference to the variable to which we can further assign — just like an ordinary variable. It could also be assigned to a reference as follows:
int &ref = ++a; // valid int &ref = a++; // invalid
Whereas if you recall how a++ works, it doesn’t immediately increment the value it holds. For brevity, you can think of it as getting incremented in the next statement. So what basically happens is that a++ returns an rvalue, which is basically just a value like the value of an expression which is not stored. You can think of a++ = 20; as follows after being processed:
int a = 10; // On compilation, a++ is replaced by the value of a which is an rvalue: 10 = 20; // Invalid // Value of a is incremented a = a + 1;
That should help to understand why a++ = 20; won’t work.
Please write comments if you find anything incorrect, or you want to share more information about the topic discussed above.
