Open In App

Find memory conflicts among multiple threads

Improve
Improve
Like Article
Like
Save
Share
Report

Consider a RAM organized in blocks. There are multiple processes running on the system. Every application gets below information.

(Thread T, Memory Block M, time t, R/W) which essentially tells that the thread T was using memory block M at time t and operation could be read or write. Memory conflict is defined as – – Multiple read operations at the same location are not cause of conflict. – One write operation between x+5 to x-5 to location M, will be cause of conflict for a thread accessing location M at time x where x is some time in standard unit of time measurement. – Example – If thread T1 accessed memory location M at time x+1 and if a thread T2 accesses location M before time x+6, then T1 and T2 are candidate of conflict given one of them does write operation. You are given with the list of threads accessing memory locations, you have to find all conflicts. Example–

Input:
(1, 512, 1, R)
(2, 432, 2, W)
(3, 512, 3, R)
(4, 932, 4, R)
(5, 512, 5, W)
(6, 932, 6, R)
(7, 835, 7, R)
(8, 432, 8, R)

Output:
Thread 1 & 3 conflict with thread 5
All other operations are safe.

We strongly recommend you to minimize your browser and try this yourself first.

The idea is to sort all threads by memory block and if memory block is same, then by time. Once we have all threads sorted, we can traverse all threads one by one. For every thread being traversed, we simply need to check previous adjacent threads of same block as threads are sorted by time. Below is C++ implementation of this idea.

CPP
// C++ program to find memory conflicts among threads 
#include<bits/stdc++.h> 
using namespace std; 

/* Structure for details of thread */
struct Thread 
{ 
    int id, memblck, time; 
    char access; 
}; 

/* Compare function needed for sorting threads 
We first sort threads on the basis of memory block, 
If they are same, then we sort on the basis of time */
bool compare(const Thread& x, const Thread& y) 
{ 
    if (x.memblck == y.memblck) 
        return x.time < y.time; 
    else return x.memblck < y.memblck; 
} 

// Function to print all conflicts among threads 
void printConflicts(Thread arr[], int n) 
{ 
    /* Sort the threads first by memblock, then by 
    time */
    sort(arr, arr+n, compare); 

    /*start from second thread till last thread*/
    for (int i = 1; i < n; i++) 
    { 
        /* As threads are sorted, We check further 
        for conflict possibility only if there 
        memblock is same*/
        if(arr[i].memblck == arr[i-1].memblck) 
        { 

            /* As threads with same block are sorted in increasing order 
            of access time. So we check possibility conflict from last 
            thread to all previous threads which access the same block 
            of memory such that the current thread access under the 
            arr[i-1].time + 5.. and if any of them does read operation 
            than conflict occurs. at any point memblock becomes different 
            or current thread moves out of vulnerable time of latest 
            previous processed thread, the loop breaks. 
            */
            if (arr[i].time <= arr[i-1].time+5) 
            { 
                int j = i-1; /* start with previous thread */

                // Find all previous conflicting threads 
                while (arr[i].memblck == arr[j].memblck && 
                        arr[i].time <= arr[j].time+5 && 
                        j >= 0) 
                { 
                    if (arr[i].access == 'W' || arr[j].access == 'W') 
                    { 
                        cout << "threads " << arr[j].id << " and "
                            << arr[i].id << " conflict.\n"; 
                    } 
                    j--; 
                } 
            } 
        } 
    } 

    cout << "All other operations are same\n"; 
} 

// Driver program to test above function 
int main() 
{ 
    Thread arr[] = { {1, 512, 1, 'R'}, {2, 432, 2, 'W'}, 
                    {3, 512, 3, 'R'}, {4, 932, 4, 'R'}, 
                    {5, 512, 5, 'W'}, {6, 932, 6, 'R'}, 
                    {7, 835, 7, 'R'}, {8, 432, 8, 'R'} 
                }; 

    int n = sizeof(arr)/sizeof(arr[0]); 
    printConflicts(arr, n); 
    return 0; 
} 
Python3
# Importing required libraries
from typing import List, Tuple
from operator import itemgetter

# Function to print all conflicts among threads
def print_conflicts(arr: List[Tuple[int, int, int, str]]) -> None:
    # Sort the threads first by memblock, then by time
    arr.sort(key=itemgetter(1, 2))

    # Start from second thread till last thread
    for i in range(1, len(arr)):
        # As threads are sorted, We check further for conflict possibility only if their memblock is same
        if arr[i][1] == arr[i-1][1]:
            # As threads with same block are sorted in increasing order of access time.
            # So we check possibility conflict from last thread to all previous threads which access the same block of memory
            # such that the current thread access under the arr[i-1].time + 5.. and if any of them does read operation than conflict occurs.
            # at any point memblock becomes different or current thread moves out of vulnerable time of latest previous processed thread, the loop breaks.
            if arr[i][2] <= arr[i-1][2] + 5:
                j = i - 1  # start with previous thread

                # Find all previous conflicting threads
                while arr[i][1] == arr[j][1] and arr[i][2] <= arr[j][2] + 5 and j >= 0:
                    if arr[i][3] == 'W' or arr[j][3] == 'W':
                        print(f"threads {arr[j][0]} and {arr[i][0]} conflict.")
                    j -= 1

    print("All other operations are same")

# Driver program to test above function
if __name__ == "__main__":
    arr = [(1, 512, 1, 'R'), (2, 432, 2, 'W'),
           (3, 512, 3, 'R'), (4, 932, 4, 'R'),
           (5, 512, 5, 'W'), (6, 932, 6, 'R'),
           (7, 835, 7, 'R'), (8, 432, 8, 'R')]

    print_conflicts(arr)

Output:

threads 3 and 5 conflict.
threads 1 and 5 conflict.
All other operations are same

Time complexity: The above solution uses sorting to sort threads. Sorting can be done in O(nLogn) time. Then it prints all conflicts. Printing all conflicts takes O(n + m) time where m is number of conflicts. So overall time complexity is O(nLogn + m).



Last Updated : 26 Mar, 2024
Like Article
Save Article
Previous
Next
Share your thoughts in the comments
Similar Reads